Both apps can unlock XDR brightness on your MacBook Pro, but they take different approaches. Here's a factual comparison to help you choose.
Vivid
Focused specifically on unlocking XDR brightness system-wide. Simple, single-purpose app that does one thing exceptionally well.
BetterDisplay
Complex display management tool with XDR brightness as one of many features. Includes extensive monitor control options.
Vivid
Works immediately with your existing brightness keys. No configuration needed - press your brightness buttons and they go twice as bright.
BetterDisplay
Offers more configuration options and controls. May require setup to enable XDR brightness features.
Vivid
Free Split Screen Mode™ lets you try full brightness on half your screen indefinitely before purchasing.
BetterDisplay
Limited 14-day free trial.
Vivid
One-time purchase starting at €10. Available on Mac App Store, Gumroad, and included in Setapp subscription.
BetterDisplay
$20 per year, then no updates.
Vivid
Dedicated to brightness: system-wide XDR brightness control using native brightness keys.
BetterDisplay
Complex display tool with multiple features beyond brightness control, including resolution management and display scaling.
Both apps support M-series MacBook Pro, Pro Display XDR, and Studio Display XDR. Your choice depends on whether you want a focused brightness tool (Vivid) or a complex display management suite (BetterDisplay).
Note: Studio Display (non-XDR) is not supported by either app.